Category: - AM Musings
San Francisco City Hall Renovated under Mayor Willie Brown
Driving down Hyde Street in the late afternoon, I glimpse San Francisco City Hall.  Most tourists take pictures of the City Hall from the plaza directly in front of the building capturing the dome and full details of the building.  This photo taken a block east at the edge of United Nations Plaza, catches a view of the James Lick/Pioneer Memorial Statue in the foreground. 

In  this light,  the gray granite fades to a gray shroud.  The statue adds perspective, scale and distance,  directing attention to the silhouette of both.  Built after the earthquake of 1906, Former Mayor Willie Brown renovated it in 1998.  He did a great job and the City should be thankful for the sensitive attention to preservation.

Accessible Drinking Fountain
The renovation triggered code upgrades throughout the building including accessibility requirements.  Mock/Wallace partner Ron Wallace was at City Hall to appear before the City Planning Commission.  He sent this photo of an accessible drinking fountain. 

The projecting drinking fountain is an obstruction.  With these metal scrolls extending to the floor, a person with poor vision using a cane could detect the obstruction and walk around it.  If new, the water fountain would probably be recessed into a niche.  In this case, it was probably not possible and the designers came up with this solution.   You probably won't see this solution used in many places, but it works here.

My sister-in-law on her wedding day.
Most of us have someone close who has some type of disability - someone who uses a wheelchair or an aged parent or grandparent who is frail.  Providing accessibility can be a challenge particularly when it can be confusing and potentially costly. 

Just following the advice of the local building department and the  California Building Code (CBC) may still leave you vulnerable.  Most accessibility lawsuits today are based not on violations of the building codes, but on the violation of civil rights under the (Federal) American with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990.  The provision of the ADA are enforced by the Federal Courts not by the local Building Department.  The Department of Justice requires State Accessibility Codes be certified by the Federal Government as meeting the minimum requirements of the ADA.  

To date, the California Building Code (CBC) has not been certified and there are significant differences between the CBC and the ADA.  The most important thing to remember is that under ADA, all buildings completed after January 26, 1992 are considered new construction and are required to be fully compliant with ADA standards unless you can demonstrate it is structurally impossible to comply.  

Enforcement is increasing and owners of non-accessible public facilities are starting to feel the pressure.  Reasonably accommodation and equivalent facilitation are not concepts specifically discussed in the Federal Standards.  Although local building departments (Building Official) may accept what you have done as equivalent facilitation, it may still fall short of meeting Federal Standards and put you in violation of the ADA.  We advise our clients at Mock/Wallace not to rely only on the judgement of the local building official, but to make their own assessment.